Socialism – Bad for Health

Younger generations in the United States, especially Gen Y/Millennials (born between 1981 and 1996) and Gen Z (born between 1997 and 2012), seem to favor socialism/Marxism, swallowing hook, line, and sinker, baited by left-leaning politicians promising lots of freebies as incentives. Some extremists are even advocating the abolition of the Police, ICE, other security governmental agencies, and worse, the elimination of the entire government we know today, in this 250-year-old USA, the great land of freedom and democracy. Obviously ignorant of the history of the dismal failure of socialism, Marxism, and communism in several countries around the world, how their political and economic decay and abridgement of all individual freedoms had led to the massive suffering of their people, socialists in America who are against capitalism and rich people in the United States, calling for redistribution of wealth, financial equality without working harder for it, are eliminating all the incentives for those driven to excel and achieve their greatest. This is what has been going on in China, Russia, and Venezuela, etc., where socialism, dictatorship, and lack of freedom, violation of human rights, have impaled the people’s lives with misery of various kinds and proportions.

Americans have been very successful in their two-and-a-half-century experiment in democracy and capitalism, with liberty in various aspects of life, economic prowess, political superiority, and international dominance. Not perfect, but still the best in the world. In the Philippines, 80 years of democracy since July 4, 1946, 40 years after the Marcos dictatorship, from Cory Aquino to the present, thank God, without such a crazy socialist movement. 

Of course, freedom is not free. The toll in human lives to gain liberty is great, but the final dividend and benefits are worth the sacrifice. Living a life of freedom and limitless opportunities is priceless.

Perhaps those who are advocating socialism for Americans should live in China, Russia, or Venezuela, etc., even for 6 months, to actually live the difference. I am sure they will all be running back home fast, except for the masochists.

Socialism impacts healthcare

The intersection of socialism and healthcare delivery is rooted in the philosophy that medical care is a fundamental human right rather than a market commodity. In a purely socialist healthcare model, the state owns, operates, and funds the healthcare infrastructure, aiming to provide universal access regardless of an individual’s wealth. While this approach seeks to eliminate financial barriers to care, its real-world implementation has yielded mixed results, ranging from equitable baseline health outcomes to catastrophic systemic collapses.

Socialist principles impact healthcare delivery primarily through central planning and universal coverage. By centralizing funding—typically through progressive (high) taxation—these systems effectively remove profit margins and insurance administrative overhead. This allows governments to focus heavily on preventative medicine, primary care, and public health campaigns, which can lead to high immunization rates and increased life expectancy across lower-income populations. Furthermore, centralized bargaining power enables the state to negotiate lower prices for pharmaceuticals and medical equipment, containing overall national health expenditures, but to the detriment of these companies and allied businesses, eventually leading to poor-quality and delayed health care.

However, the state-directed model introduces significant structural challenges. Without market mechanisms to balance supply and demand, socialist healthcare systems frequently rely on non-price rationing. This often manifests as prolonged wait times for elective surgeries, specialized diagnostic imaging, and consultations with specialists. Bureaucracy can stifle administrative efficiency, and rigid state budgets may lead to underinvestment in cutting-edge medical technologies and infrastructure.

Furthermore, when healthcare professional salaries are strictly capped by the government, it can result in a “brain drain,” where top medical talent migrates to countries with market-driven, higher-compensating systems, like the United States.

The most prominent examples of failed socialist healthcare delivery occur when systemic political and economic crises dismantle state funding. Venezuela serves as a contemporary case of severe healthcare failure under a socialist framework.

Following the expansion of state-controlled medical programs under the “Barrio Adentro” initiative, subsequent economic collapse, hyperinflation, and state mismanagement left the country’s public hospitals without basic medical supplies, electricity, or running water. This triggered a resurgence of eradicated infectious diseases like malaria and measles alongside a massive exodus of medical professionals.

Similarly, the historical healthcare system of the Soviet Union experienced a severe decline in its later decades. While the Semashko system initially succeeded in combating infectious diseases and establishing widespread geographic access, chronic underfunding by the 1970s and 1980s led to a stark decline in the quality of care. Soviet hospitals suffered from shortages of basic disposables, such as sterile syringes, and fell significantly behind Western nations in medical technology and specialized treatments.

In summary, socialism in healthcare prioritizes equity and preventative access, often successfully lowering financial barriers for the general population. However, its long-term viability depends entirely on the economic stability of the state. When centralized economies falter or mismanage resources, the healthcare system loses its sole funding mechanism, transforming the promise of universal care into severe shortages and systemic failure. This eventually happens to all socialist/Marxist/communist nations.

As for liberty, these undemocratic and restrictive systems, in reality, abridge your freedom to say what you want and do what you want, without fearing for your life. While they seem to promise free this and free that, these are material things that are not worth the loss of freedom we now enjoy in this land of the brave and of the free. Those freebies are short-lived and soon disappear.

All we have to do in a capitalist environment is to work diligently and earn an honest wage, which will allow us to buy those things and live with self-reliance and pride. Plus human rights and human dignity as bonuses.

When it comes to healthcare and its delivery to the public, the United States is second to none. People from neighboring and far countries fly to the United States for state-of-the-art diagnostic and specialized medical and surgical therapeutic procedures, which are readily and promptly accessible to all.

In this age of information, where Dr. Google is on-call 24/7, it behooves everyone to learn about the nightmares of socialism, Marxism, and communism before unwittingly and unwisely jumping into the fires of these repressive, authoritarian, and human-rights-abusive systems with ignorance and stupidity.

* * *

The opinions, beliefs and viewpoints expressed by the author do not necessarily reflect the opinions, beliefs and viewpoints of the Asian Journal, its management, editorial board and staff.

* * *

Philip S. Chua, MD, FACS, FPCS, a Cardiac Surgeon Emeritus based in Northwest Indiana and Las Vegas, Nevada, is an international medical lecturer/author, Health Advocate, newspaper columnist, and Chairman of the Filipino United Network-USA, a 501(c)3 humanitarian foundation in the United States. He was a decorated recipient of the Indiana Sagamore of the Wabash Award in 1995, conferred by then Indiana Governor, later Senator, and then presidential candidate, Evan Bayh. Other Sagamore past awardees include President Harry Truman, President George HW Bush, Muhammad Ali, and astronaut Gus Grissom (Wikipedia). Websites: FUN8888.com, Today.SPSAtoday.com, and philipSchua.com   Email: scalpelpen@gmail.com

One thought on “Socialism – Bad for Health”

  1. A useful next step would be to separate healthcare financing from the broader political system before drawing conclusions. The claim that “long-term viability depends entirely on the economic stability of the state” would be easier to assess alongside comparable measures of funding, staffing, wait times, and access across countries and periods. That would also help distinguish policy effects from the effects of economic collapse or mismanagement.
    My relevant affiliation is with AI product photography.

Comments are closed.

Back To Top